language files what overrides what

Press Ctrl / CMD + C to copy this to your clipboard.

Copied to clipboard

Flag this post as spam?

This post will be reported to the moderators as potential spam to be looked at

Trent Grandey 22 posts 143 karma points

Jul 11, 2017 @ 19:59
0

Language Files - What overrides what?
I have 3 language files that I am working with. I'm only using en-US. That is my browser's setting and it is the default setting in the web.

/Config/Lang/en-US.user.xml /Umbraco/Config/Lang/en.xml /Umbraco/Config/Lang/en-US.xml

I'm targeting one alias for the purposes of this post. (I've removed the other placeholders from this example, but they exist in the actual files)
```
<language>
  <area alias="placeholders">
    <key alias="usernameHint">Your username</key>
  </area>
</language>
```
If I put a different value in each file, which should win?

Currently, if I have a different value in all 3, "/Umbraco/Config/Lang/en.xml" wins. I thought that "/Config/Lang/en-US.users.xml" would override all others.

If I remove it from "/Umbraco/Config/Lang/en.xml", it will read the value from the "/Config/Lang/en-US.users.xml".

If I remove it from "/Umbraco/Config/Lang/en.xml" AND "/Config/Lang/en-US.users.xml", it will read the value from the "/Umbraco/Config/Lang/en-US.xml" file.

I'm confused. Again, I would expect "/Config/Lang/en-US.user.xml" to override the other 2 files.

Am I wrong?

Thanks for the help!

Trent Umbraco version 7.6.3 assembly: 1.0.6361.21154
Copy Link
Chriztian Steinmeier 2726 posts 8320 karma points MVP 4x admin c-trib

Jul 11, 2017 @ 21:46

0

Hi Trent,

Very interesting!

It would be very nice to investigate this and find out if there's a bug, or if it's just the docs that are misleading...

As you, I would expect the ~/Config/Lang/{language}.user.xml file to "win" for any alias specified in it.

Just to be clear: You write .users.xml but the docs states .user.xml - yours is just a typo, right?

Another thing that could be in play, could be that the .user.xml files might have to match the language code exactly? (In your example you're trying to override a setting in /Umbraco/Config/Lang/en-US.xml with a setting in /Config/Lang/en.user.xml or am I reading it wrong?)

/Chriztian

Copy Link
Trent Grandey 22 posts 143 karma points

Jul 12, 2017 @ 12:01

0

Hi Chriztian,

The users.xml was in fact a typo. And The filename in the /Config/Lang folder is en-US.user.xml.

To me, the fact that if I remove the setting from one file and it then reads from another, that tells me that the files are all correctly named. If I couldn't get it to ever read from one particular file, then I would think I had a file out of place or named wrong or had my XML misformed.

I think I may have to dig into the Core and see if I can tell anything. It is really not a big issue, but it just doesn't make sense to me.

Thanks for your reply!

Trent

Copy Link
Nicholas Westby 2005 posts 6843 karma points c-trib

Jul 11, 2017 @ 21:53

0

I have 3 language files that I am working with. I'm only using en-US. That is my browser's setting and it is the default setting in the web.

What language is your Umbraco user set to? I think the default is "English (United Kingdom)":

Copy Link
Trent Grandey 22 posts 143 karma points

Jul 12, 2017 @ 12:02

0

Hi Nicholas,

For all users, I had changed that to English (United States) upon install.

Thanks for your reply!

Trent

Copy Link
is working on a reply...

This forum is in read-only mode while we transition to the new forum.

You can continue this topic on the new forum by tapping the "Continue discussion" link below.

Please Sign in or register to post replies

Flag this post as spam?

Language Files - What overrides what?