I have added to the NewComment Event Handler, it sends an email, but don't get the ID of the Comment which would be useful to make further changes.

Guess you'll have to customize the source for you needs, you can find it here http://ucomment.codeplex.com

ok, wanted to check first that I wasn't missing anything, thanks.

Strange, because looking at the source code, the ID should be set before, so don't know why it isn't being passed through to OnCommentCreated

Yeah looks like it,time to debug then ;)

I am just using

sender.Id.ToString()

in

public void NewComment(Comment sender, EventArgs e)
        {}

but its coming out as '0'

I see its this

line 146:                      c.Id = sqlHelper.ExecuteScalar<int>(..

it returns null

Fixed:

Need to change this in Cooment.cs:

   c.Id = sqlHelper.ExecuteScalar<int>(
                @"insert into Comment(mainid,nodeid,name,email,website,comment,spam,created)
                        values(@mainid,@nodeid,@name,@email,@website,@comment,@spam,@created)
                    SELECT CAST(scope_identity() AS int)",
                 sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@mainid", -1),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@nodeid", c.ParentNodeId),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@name", c.Name),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@email", c.Email),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@website", c.Website),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@comment", c.CommenText),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@spam", c.Spam),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@created", c.Created),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@approved", c.Approved),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@thumbsUp", 0),
                sqlHelper.CreateParameter("@thumbsDown", 0));

is working on a reply...